Proposed Addition to League Bylaws:

The Mulligan Rule:

Each team owner will be granted one Mulligan per fantasy football season. The Mulligan can be used to replace any player who exits the game due to injury with an eligible player from their bench who plays the same position. Once a Mulligan is used, it cannot be restored or used again for the same season.

Pros:

• Fairness and Level Playing Field: The Mulligan Rule promotes fairness by offering all team owners an equal opportunity to replace players lost to injuries during a matchup. This ensures that no team faces undue disadvantages due to unforeseen circumstances, leveling the playing field for all participants.

• Enhanced Strategy and Engagement: With the Mulligan Rule in effect, team owners will need to adopt a more strategic approach to roster management. Carefully assessing bench players' potential to replace injured starters adds depth to the game and keeps owners engaged throughout the season.

• Reduced Impact of Chance: Injuries are an inherent part of sports, and losing key players early in a matchup can lead to frustration. The Mulligan Rule mitigates the impact of chance by providing a safety net, shifting outcomes towards being more reliant on owners' strategic decisions rather than unforeseen injuries.

Cons:

• Limited Use Concerns: The restriction of one Mulligan per season might cause frustration if team owners face multiple injuries within a short period and exhaust their mulligan opportunities.

• Added Complexity: Introducing an additional rule could add complexity to the league's gameplay and scoring system. Team owners, particularly newcomers, might require time to fully grasp and adapt to the Mulligan Rule.

• Impact on Streaming Strategy: With the rise in benching backup quarterbacks, the availability of quarterbacks for streaming purposes may decrease. The traditional strategy of streaming quarterbacks week to week based on matchups might become less viable in the league.

Predictions:

• Increased Backup Quarterbacks: The Mulligan Rule's implementation is likely to result in more team owners prioritizing backup quarterbacks on their benches. Given that quarterbacks often earn the highest scores, this strategic move aims to ensure seamless replacements in case of injuries.

• Limited Streaming Options: The increase in benching backup quarterbacks may reduce the pool of available quarterbacks for streaming purposes. Consequently, team owners will need to be more thoughtful in their roster decisions when seeking temporary quarterback replacements.

• Strategic Roster Management: The presence of the Mulligan Rule will encourage team owners to build deeper and more diverse rosters. Viable replacements for injured players become crucial, making bench player assessments an essential part of roster management throughout the season.